Welcome to The HayLoft, Lancaster County’s ice cream shop.
We serve soft-serve ice cream and hand-dipped ice cream, Italian ice, soft pretzels with dips, and other fine treats. Learn more about our menu.
HayLoft donates all profits to Allegany Boys Camp, a year-round residential wilderness camp for boys ages 9-16 who are struggling in their homes and at school. Learn more about our mission.
Our Mission
The Ice Cream Shop
Hayloft Ice Cream is Lancaster’s new ice cream parlor, located just west of New Holland in Leola, PA. We offer delicious homemade ice cream flavors, soft pretzels, and other treats.
The ducks and fish can be fed at the nearby pond, and children love playing on the beautiful new playground. Our spacious deck and a pavilion by the playground provide shade and shelter for outdoor seating. We invite you to come and see the unique interior of the building representing the boys’ camp we are working for.
Allegany Boys Camp
All proceeds go to support the work of Allegany Boys Camp, a year-round residential wilderness camp for boys ages 9-16 who are struggling in their homes and at school. You can support the work of the camp through your purchase of ice cream, soft pretzels, and other treats. More information about the camp is available at www.alleganyboyscamp.org.
A camper wrote,
“In the past year I have learned a lot at camp. Standing in a circle, after you see yourself or someone that has a problem that needs solved you gather together to help solve the problem.
But I’ll be honest with you, when you see the person is being stubborn and that they don’t want your help at all, you start to feel inside, why waste my time on them. It only takes time, experience, and some thinking. And then you’ll look back and say, my time was worth it just to help them and see them make progress in their life.
Because God didn’t give you life to waste time only on the things that are all about yourself. He put you here to help other people in their hard times in life, and to invest your time to help them make the progress they need. These are some of the things I have learned about simply solving problems through my everyday life at camp.”
Our Menu
Flavors of Italian ice, pretzel log, ice cream, and soft serve may vary by month. Contact us for the current month’s flavors.
Ice Cream Treats
Soft Serve
Vanilla
Chocolate
Twist
Pumpkin Spice
Caramel Macchiato
Pumpkin Caramel Twist
Sundae
Black Raspberry
Butterscotch
Caramel
Chocolate Peanut Butter Marshmallow
Dusty Road
Hot Fudge
Peanut Butter
Pineapple
Strawberry
Barn Blaster
Andes Mint
Brownie Bits
Black Raspberry Cheesecake
Butterfinger
Cappuccino
Chocolate Chip
Coffee Bean
Cookie Dough
Grasshopper
Heath
M&M
Oreo
Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup
Reese’s Pieces
Snickers
Strawberry Cheesecake
Turtle
Gelatis
Soft Serve & Ice
Banana Split
Hot Fudge Brownie
Root Beer Float
Hand Scooped
Black Raspberry
Butter Pecan
Chocolate
Coffee Crunch
Coconut
Cookies n Cream
Cotton Candy
Key Lime Cheesetart
Lemon Bliss
Mint Chip
Orange Creamsicle
Peanut Butter Overload
Salty Caramel Crunch
S’mores
Triple Chcolate
Vanilla
No Sugar Added Vanilla
Italian Ice
Flavors may vary month to month.
Blue Raspberry
Cotton Candy
Root Beer
Black Raspberry
Peanut Butter
Tropical Swirl
Strawberry Lemonade
Pina Colada
Lemon
Orange
Mango
Green Apple
Watermelon
Lemon Lime
Cherry
Barn Splash
7-Up & any flavor Italian Ice
Cold Brew Shake
Mocha and Caramel
Ice Shake
Lattes – hot & iced
Baked Treats
Soft Pretzels
Regular Pretzel Sticks
Garlic Parmesan
Sour Cream & Onion
Cinnamon Sugar
Dips
Cheese
Honey Mustard
Pretzel Log
Meatball –this Flavor varies month to month.
Cheesesteak
Chicken Ranch
Soup & Sandwich
Cup or Bowl of Soup
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Cheeseburger
Classic Cheeseburger
Grilled Cheese
French Fries
Campfire Special – fries topped with pulled pork, cheese, BBQ sauce, scallions
Large & Small
GelatisIce Cream CakeCold Brew ShakeCampfire Special
We were thrilled to learn that the workers were volunteers & the proceeds benefit The Allegany Boys Camp. Our hot fudge sundaes were delicious. I bought some cinnamon honey butter, one for myself and one as a gift. We'll definitely go again! ❤
Nancy Raezer November 2, 2019
We loved everything about this place! The staff are so nice, the building is clean, and the pond takes the experience to the next level. We will definitely be back!!
Rebecca Garrett June 19, 2018
Extremely good ice creams!!! I’ll be back before you know.
Danijel Mirkov June 1, 2019
Love their pretzels, soft ice cream, and black raspberry sundaes!!
Naomi Stoltzfus November 15, 2018
Always friendly efficient service, and the best soft pretzels and ice cream!